JonNash 9:13 Fri Sep 19
Our mangers in order
|
|
Put them in order best first
Lyall
Macari
Bonds
Redknapp
Roeder
Pardew
Curbs
Zola
Grant
Substantial Samuel
2 groups there for me and that bottom group is big and utter shit.
1) Lyall - 85-86
2) Bonds - legend and best win ratio
3) Curbs - nothing special but did ok
4) Redknapp - 5th in 98-99 was good
5) Pardew - FA Cup was good but not much else
6) Macari - thieving jock cunt, enough for a yes vote by himself
7) Zola - good football at times but shit management
8) BFS - pains me but he isn't the shittest IMHO
9) Roeder - had the decency to be genuinely ill when he left
10) Grant - never been so depressed by a manager in my life
Roeder gets special points for being our only permanent manager Wikipedia couldn't find anything to say about, good or bad. Cunt
|
|
|
Replies - In Chronological Order ( Show Newest Messages First)
simon.s
9:18 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
Any list that has Roeder above Pardew, and even our current Manager, must have been compiled by a simpleton.
|
Sxboy_66
9:18 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
What a very odd thread.
|
simon.s
9:21 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
Ah, you didn't. I read it wrong. That'll be the drink....
|
Too Much Too Young
9:22 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
Where the fuck is Ron Greenwood you mug?
|
,
9:23 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
Greenwood definitely the best for me.
|
JonNash
9:25 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
Agreed that Roeder above Pardew makes you a simpleton which is why I have Pardew at 5 and Roeder at 9. BFS is a cunt and I want him gone but he hasn't relegated us yet so can't be below some of them, plus the squad right now is decent. Only time has Roeder ahead or Pardew, not much I can do about that.
|
JonNash
9:27 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
Apologies on Greenwood but I was born in 74 so never saw us under him so couldn't really comment on supporting under his reign
|
SecondOpinion
9:27 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
Away in a manger?
|
Far Cough
9:29 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
Where's Syd King and Chas Paynter?
Boooo Jon Nash out
|
Nagel
9:31 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
WTF is Curbs doing at number 3?
Biggest transfer budget of any manager we've ever had. Bought a load of shit. Couldn't finish higher than Pardew, Zola and Roeder all did in their first ever seasons as PL managers.
I'd put him just above Allardyce.
|
ray winstone
9:32 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
I prefer STRONGBOW.
|
Pagey
9:35 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
simon.s 9:18 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
Any list that has Roeder above Pardew, and even our current Manager, must have been compiled by a simpleton.
--------------
Once again someone can't wait to call someone else a simpleton (why has that word become so popular?) and they actually end up making themselves look like a prize cock.
|
Sarge
9:35 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
1) (sir) John Lyall
2) Harry
3) Billy
4) Zola
5) Macari
6) Pards
7) BFS
8) curbs
999) grant
1000) roeder
|
Bromley Reject
9:36 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
Ted Fenton won't be too pleased either
|
Texas Iron
9:39 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
First list is obviously chronological in order of managing...second is obviously the posters evaluation...
Can't agree on Curbishley...BFS should be higher...worst is Grant...Zola should be lower...
I wasn't around for Lyall ...Bonds...Macari ...or most of Redknapp...
First year Roeder did well...second no cash and illness...
Pardew was very good until he lost the dressing room and off pitch shenanigans...
Zola was naive...too easily manipulated by Nani & Duxbury ...
Curbishley was boring...bad buying decisions...took too long to get US safe from delegation...had 21 games to do it...went to last day at OT ...
Grant was incompetent and had switched off...couldn't manage average players or motivate them...
BFS is boring...but has done everything asked of him...except attractive football...
|
Too Much Too Young
9:45 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
What about Sir Trevor of Brooking?
Why isn't he listed?
|
zico
9:45 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
From King to Lyall was probably West Ham for me. Might have rose tinted specs on after reading the history books but the Club seemed to be run the right way and it had an identity certainly epitomised IMO by Greenwood and Lyall. Yes some god awful results along the way but under them it was what West Ham was all about. A lot of it died after they sacked Lyall.
It was West Ham again under Billy and whatever you think of him Harry carried on the tradition but it's been a different Club since.
|
Hermit Road
9:45 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
If we'd have kept curbs we would have out-performed Everton and be in a much stronger position because of it.
|
dolph
9:45 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
"i wasn't around for most of redknapp"
where were you?
|
Far Cough
9:51 Fri Sep 19
Re: Our mangers in order
|
I wasn't around for Bonds Macari and the beginning of Redknapp
Reason?
I was in the States and the internet wasn't around yet, well it was around but fuck all much was on it and I expect Tex has the same reason?
|
| 
